Updated Oct 16, 2026, 1:45 PM ET
House · 3 November 2026

NY-17 House 2026

59.3% DCait Conley leads TruthIndex™Toss-up
Polymarket
58.5%
Kalshi
60.5%
Spread
2.0 pts
24h
–
7 days
+1.8
Updated
Oct 16, 2026, 1:45 PM ET
Latest coverage

Live News

Recent coverage for NY-17 House.

  1. Democrat Refuses To Let Congressman 'Mansplain' Rape, Domestic Abuse To Her During Fiery Debate

    “I don’t think those types of folks belong in Congress, and I don’t believe that people who condone that type of behavior belong in Congress either,” Conley declared.

    aol.comConleyAlso in aol.ca
  2. Lawler's Dem opponent Cait Conley throws Hochul under the bus in jaw-dropping public burn

    Cait Conley delivered the jaw-dropping burn this week, becoming the second Democratic congressional candidate to publicly distance themselves from Hochul ahead of next month’s midterms.

    New York PostConleyGendebien
  3. QUICK CLIP: Cait Conley Brutally Fact Checks Mike Lawler’s Record on Data Centers During NY-17 Debate
    Democratic Congressional Campaign CommitteeConley

Cait Conley, last 60 days

How to read this chart

The green line is the TruthIndex™, the chance of this outcome. It combines the prices on both venues and gives more weight to the venue with more money in its order book. The two thinner lines are Polymarket's and Kalshi's own prices, and the grey band between them shows how far apart the two venues are.

The pale bands behind the lines are the rating zones (Toss-up, Lean, Likely and Safe), so you can see when the race moved from one rating to another. Move along the chart, or use the arrow keys, to read the values for each day.

More in Methodology
TruthIndex™PolymarketKalshiGap between the venuesRating zones

All outcomes

OutcomeTruthIndex™PolymarketKalshiSpread24h
DCait Conley 59.3% 58.5% 60.5% 2.0 pts –
RMike Lawler 40.5% 40.5% 40.5% 0.0 pts –

Share this race

Embed the live card

The card updates on your page every 5 minutes and links back to this race. Paste the code into an HTML or embed block; it fits any width up to 680 pixels.

<iframe src="https://midterms.nijinn.io/house/ny-17/embed.html" title="NY-17 House: live odds from Nijinn" style="width:100%;max-width:680px;height:400px;border:0" loading="lazy" scrolling="no"></iframe>
<p style="margin:4px 0 0;font:12px/1.4 Arial,sans-serif">Live odds: <a href="https://midterms.nijinn.io/house/ny-17/?utm_source=embed&amp;utm_medium=embed-credit&amp;utm_campaign=midterms-2026&amp;utm_content=house-ny-17">Nijinn US Midterms 2026</a></p>

Where frames are not allowed, the image card, linked to this race, updates with each refresh:

<a href="https://midterms.nijinn.io/house/ny-17/?utm_source=embed&amp;utm_medium=embed-image&amp;utm_campaign=midterms-2026&amp;utm_content=house-ny-17"><img src="https://midterms.nijinn.io/house/ny-17/card-landscape.png" alt="NY-17 House: odds from Nijinn" width="600" height="315" style="max-width:100%;height:auto;border:0"></a>

Candidates & Background

Cait Conley

Cait Conley

Democratic

Cait Conley, a Democrat and former Army officer who led election security work at the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, faces Republican incumbent Mike Lawler for New York's 17th congressional district in 2026.

Mike Lawler

Mike Lawler

Republican U.S. Representative for New York's 17th congressional district (since 2023)

Mike Lawler, a Republican who has represented New York's 17th congressional district since 2023, faces Democrat Cait Conley, a former Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency senior advisor, in his 2026 re-election race.

Born 1986 · Suffern, New York

Margin of victory

Each venue's margin market, shown on its own: the two venues set their ranges differently.

Kalshi5.8K contracts

New York's 17th District margin of victory

Lawler, 3+ pts
28.0%
Lawler, 6+ pts
16.0%
Lawler, 9+ pts
8.3%
Source: Kalshi market

Kalshi8.8K contracts

New York's 17th District margin of victory

Conley, 1+ pts
52.0%
Conley, 3+ pts
41.5%
Conley, 6+ pts
28.0%
Conley, 9+ pts
15.5%
Conley, 12+ pts
7.1%
Conley, 15+ pts
7.7%
implied
Source: Kalshi market

Polymarket$16.3K traded

NY-17 House Election Margin of Victory

Republican 12%+
3.0%
Republican 9-12%
1.3%
Republican 6-9%
2.5%
Republican 3-6%
4.6%
Republican 0-3%
22.1%
Democrat 0-3%
17.5%
Democrat 3-6%
26.5%
Democrat 6-9%
21.5%
Democrat 9-12%
4.2%
Democrat 12%+
6.0%
Source: Polymarket market

Each venue's market

Polymarket$68.2K traded

Prices which party wins.

Cait Conley: Counted · bid 58.0% / ask 59.0% · $38.2K within 5 pts

This market will resolve according to the party of the candidate who wins the NY-17 congressional district seat in the U.S. House of Representatives in the 2026 midterm elections. The midterm elections will take place on November 3, 2026. ​​A candidate's party will be determined by their ballot-listed or otherwise identifiable affiliation with that party at the time all of the 2026 House elections are conclusively called by this market's resolution sources. A candidate without a ballot-listed affiliation to either the Democrat or Republican parties will be considered a member of one of these parties based on the party with which they most recently expressed their intent to caucus at the time all of the House elections are conclusively called by this market's resolution sources. This market will resolve based on the result of the election as indicated by a consensus of credible reporting. If there is ambiguity, this market will resolve based solely on the official results as reported by the United States government, specifically the Federal Election Commission (https://www.fec.gov/).

Full rules on Polymarket

Kalshi307.2K contracts traded

Prices which party wins.

Cait Conley: Counted · bid 60.0% / ask 61.0% · $26.9K within 5 pts

Contract shown: Cait Conley

If the House member sworn in for NY-17 for the term beginning in 2027 is a member of the Democratic Party, then the market resolves to Yes.

This market is eligible for accelerated determination after a consensus of media organizations project the winner. See full rules for details.

Full rules on Kalshi